Papers criticizing ECE


By rather fast correcting a previous APPB referee error our Comment on the Evans paper

http://th-www.if.uj.edu.pl/acta/vol38/pdf/v38p2211.pdf

Comments on ``Spin Connection Resonance in Gravitational General Relativity''
by G.W. Bruhn, F.W. Hehl, A. Jadczyk

has appeared in ACTA PHYSICA POLONICA B:

We comment on the recent article of M.W. Evans, "Spin Connection Resonance in Gravitational General Relativity", Acta Phys. Pol. B {38}, 2211 (2007). We point out that the equations underlying Evans' theory are highly problematic. Moreover, we demonstrate that the so-called ``spin connection resonance'', predicted by Evans, cannot be derived from the equation he used. We provide an exact solution of Evans' corresponding equation and show that it has definitely no resonance solutions.

Full article:
http://th-www.if.uj.edu.pl/acta/vol39/pdf/v39p0051.pdf


Further Articles on ECE theory in refereed journals:

G.W. Bruhn, No energy to be extracted from the vacuum, 2006 Physica Scripta 74 535-536, Abstract, Full text, Preprint.

G.W. Bruhn, No Lorentz property of M W Evans' O(3)-symmetry law, 2006 Physica Scripta 74 537-538, Abstract, Full text, Preprint.

G.W. Bruhn, On the Non-Lorentz Invariance of M.W. Evans O(3)-Symmetry Law, Foundations of Physics 38 (2008) 3-6, Springer, arXiv

F.W. Hehl, An assessment of Evans' unified field theory I, Foundations of Physics 38 (2008) 7-37, Springer, ISSN 0015-9018 (Print) 1572-9516 (Online), 10.1007/s10701-007-9190-0
Abstract arXiv

F.W. Hehl and Y.N. Obukhov, An assessment of Evansí unified field theory II, Foundations of Physics 2007, Springer, arXiv

A.L. Trovon de Carvalho and W. A. Rodrigues Jr., The Non Sequitur Mathematics and Physics of the 'New Electrodynamics' of the AIAS Group, Random Operators and Stochastic Equations 9, 161-206 (2001). arXiv

W.A. Rodrigues Jr. and Q. A. G. de Souza, An Ambiguous Statement Called 'Tetrad Postulate' and the Correct Field Equations Satisfied by the Tetrad Fields, Int. J. Mod. Phys. D 14, 2095-2150 (2005). arXiv

W.A. Rodrigues Jr., Differential Forms on Riemannian (Lorentzian) and Riemann-Cartan Structures and Some Applications to Physics, to appear Ann. Fond. L. de Broglie (special issue on torsion) (2008) , arXiv

E. Wielandt, The superposition principle of waves not fulfilled under M W Evans' O(3) hypothesis, 2006 Physica Scripta 74 539-540, Abstract, arXiv, Preprint.


Further Links to some recent comments on Evans' notes

(08.01.2008) An Editorial Note by G. 't Hooft in Found. Phys.

(29.01.2008) Remarks on Evans' Web Note #100-Section 7: The Sagnac Effect

(25.01.2008) Remarks on Evans' Web Note #100-Section 6: SCR

(16.01.2008) Remarks on Evans' Web Note #100-Section 5: EM field

(15.01.2008) Papers criticizing ECE

(08.01.2008) Remarks on Evans' Web Note #100-Section 4: The Aharonov Bohm effect

(05.01.2008) Remarks on Evans' Web Note #100-Section 3: Field and Wave equation

(01.01.2008) Remarks on Evans' Web Note #100-Section 2: Torsion and Bianchi identity

(27.12.2007) Remarks on Evans' Web Note #103

(10.12.2007) How Dr. Evans refutes the whole EH Theory

(26.10.2007) Review of the FoPL paper "The Evans Lemma of Differential Geometry"

(09.04.2007) Review of the FoPL paper "The Evans Lemma of Differential Geometry"




HOME